Philadelphia Civil Trial Deemed Longest and Most Costly in State History

Posted by Gary Brod | Feb 10, 2017 | 0 Comments

According to a recent article, a settlement has finally been reached in the case of the fatal 2013 Salvation Army building collapse in Philadelphia. The civil trial has been declared the lengthiest trial in Philadelphia court history, as well as the most expensive payout ever granted in a case. The Plaintiffs as a group agreed to settle for $227 million dollars to conclude this trial. At first blush this may sound like an incomprehensible sum but the losses in suffering and human lives were arguably profound and incalculable.

Litigation persisted for a whopping 17 weeks before it was abruptly stopped by the announcement of the multi-million dollar settlement. This award will be divided equitably based upon the severity of the losses among the families of seven deceased victims and 12 survivors who were severely injured as a result of the building's collapse on June 5, 2013. Both the Salvation Army and building owner Richard Basciano, a New York real estate speculator, were found liable for the casualties and injuries of the plaintiffs. One of the most severely injured survivors, a 52 year old widow who was found barely alive under the rubble lost the entire lower half of her body below her hips and lifecare costs to support and maintain her were estimated at $50 million.

Basciano, 91, was hoping to redevelop properties he had been promised for 20 years. When contractors came to remove the brick building. Its structure was left unsupported, leaving the brick walls to crumble on occupants within the store. According to the lawsuit, the Salvation Army had received numerous emails regarding the threat of a collapse in the thrift store for months while under construction. Salvation Army employees refused to inform their customers of the forewarnings and did absolutely nothing to ensure their safety.

In the jury's liability verdict, they assigned the charity 75% at fault for the shoppers injured in the collapse. The jury found Basciano and his corporation responsible for 18% of the harm to shoppers harmed and killed in the collapse, he was assigned an additional 68% of the harm to thrift shop employees that were killed and injured. These percentages were based on findings that Basciano failed to research the qualifications of architect Plato Marinakos, who had no sufficient experience in monitoring such a major project. Testimonials also proved that Basciano also received Marinakos' recommendation of contractor Griffin Campbell, an inexperienced and unlicensed contractor to provide his services for the demolition.

The defendants decided to reach a settlement three days after the emotional and moving testimonies of survivors and families of the deceased. The jury had already begun to calculate monetary compensation for the damages suffered by the plaintiffs, but both parties were aware that after the testimonials, a settlement was likely.

One of the lawyers for the plaintiffs said the settlement sent a message to the business community that he hopes rings loud and clear. “If you cut corners and endanger the public, you will be held accountable".

Had the trial continued, punitive damages against the defendants would have been assigned.

If you or someone you know has been injured as a result of the negligence of an individual, corporation or entity due to faulty construction or demolition, they may be eligible for compensation if seriously injured. Don't let those who have hurt you or a loved one continue operating without being held accountable for their actions. Call the Brod Law Firm today for a consultation toll free at 1-888-435-7946 (1-888-HELPWIN) or contact them online.

About the Author

Gary Brod

Attorney Gary Brod is the founder of The Brod Law Firm. For more than three decades, he has relentlessly championed the rights of injured people to receive just compensation for their serious injuries. In recognition of his hard work, dedication to his clients and results obtained on their behalf Gary Brod has received national acclaim for his achievements by leading lawyer and consumer rating organizations for the highest ratings possible by both peers and clients.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Speak To An Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer Today

Trusted and respected for over 30 yrs we have been the law firm of choice for injured Pennsylvania accident victims and their families Whether you were injured in a car accident, slip and fall or have been the victim of medical malpractice we are here to help right now. Our clients are our best spokespersons.

Choose Wisely

We know this is your one case and no stone is left unturned regardless of the severity of your injury or if it concerns the death of a loved one. We know how the insurance companies operate inside and out. We have the skills and experience to effectively communicate the magnitude of your pain and suffering in a manner that will generate the maximum recovery for you. Speak to attorney Gary Brod today for no charge.